Graded Discussions | Teen Ink

Graded Discussions

November 4, 2016
By Mcasimir02 BRONZE, Valley Stream, New York
Mcasimir02 BRONZE, Valley Stream, New York
1 article 0 photos 0 comments

I liked Augusta S’s article “Graded Discussions” because I can strongly relate to it. In her article, Stockman describes her dislike for the pressure and anxiety she feels as a result of restricted expression during discussions. Augusta and I have similar feelings on how a discussion in school should be like. It should be an occasion  where students can openly exchange ideas about topics and offer their own opinions. In stockman’s case, she feels nervous about her discussion in her social studies class, because she is given a numerical grade based on the “right answers” in a discussion rather than effort, explanation, and participation. As I enter into high school I reflect on a personal level, I realize that what were once fun ways to raise participation points and stimulate the mind have turned into numerically evaluated conversations with robotic flow and sound. In the eighth grade I was always nervous to go class because I had to come up with a religiously memorized contribution instead of brainstorming my thoughts and sharing with the class. However, because graded class discussions have become routine, they are now just as fun as reading out of a textbook, and excellent comparison made by Augusta in her article.


The author's comments:

It was very interseting for me to find such an article that completely summarized my experiences in eighth grade. The whole time through I was thinking "Yes, someone is actually experiencing this!" It was refreshing honestly, to read about someone who doesn't just go with the flow and assume that everything done in school is correct. Because that's not necessarily true.


Similar Articles

JOIN THE DISCUSSION

This article has 0 comments.