Big IS Beautiful | Teen Ink

Big IS Beautiful

December 17, 2009
By Alix Nestel BRONZE, Manchester, Missouri
Alix Nestel BRONZE, Manchester, Missouri
2 articles 0 photos 0 comments

Size 14 is the average of women across the country, so why is it impossible for me as a size 14 to go throughout the day without getting some kind of disparaging remark about my weight? I have been called every “fat” name in the book: blimp, whale, tubby, Michelin man, fatty, butter ball… need I go on? I get dirty looks persistently, and I have been denied service at many clothing stores. No woman of any size should go through that type of humiliation. I haven’t said anything about overweight men because, "Overweight women are twice as vulnerable as men, and discrimination strikes much earlier in their lives," according to Geoffrey Bennett’s article about over weight people in America.

The media say being overweight is ugly. What gives them the right to say that? I’m not saying it’s all right to be seven hundred pounds and the only way of getting out of your home is by knocking down a wall and craning you out, but why is it wrong to be a healthy, yet more voluptuous, woman? Every commercial and television show displays girls that are no bigger than a size 2 and then they have one bigger girl on the show that hates the world and, of course, she’s extremely unpopular.

It’s not realistic. In my reality, I’m big. I get made fun of all of the time, but I don’t hate the world, and I definitely don’t consider myself unpopular. The only truth to these shows is that the skinny girl gets the boy. Bottom line, fat isn’t hot to guys but is it the fat itself or the excessive lack of confidence these girls have that’s the turn off? I would go with the second answer. Fluffy girls don’t feel confident because there’s not enough effort being put out to change their minds. The only shows that these girls watch are ridiculous ones such as More to Love. This show is basically telling every full-figured girl that only a full-figured boy could love her. What kind of message is that to girls who already have no confidence?

The Dove Foundation is feuding against every other company to prove to girls that flaws are fabulous. They even have a song in a commercial that says, “Do your eyes sit wide. Does your nose go to the side? Does your elbow have a crinkle? Do your knees sort of wrinkle. Does your chest tend to Frankel? Do your ears sorta wiggle? Does your hair make it giggle? Does your neck crow long? Do your hips sing a song? Do your ears hang low” and I love it because being overweight isn’t the only flaw that causes women to hide from their reflection. Dove is allowing women to relate to one another in saying that we all have flaws that make us different, not ugly and I respect them for that.

Very few women these days are famous and overweight because the number on the scale overshadows their talent. Take Adele for example, she is an incredible singer and instead of people applauding her for her aptitude for singing, she is laughed at and criticized for being a big girl. Then there’s Jessica Simpson. She was a symbol of perfection to everyone while I was growing up but recently she put on weight and all hell breaks lose. Every tabloid is screaming, “FATTY!” while majority of them probably are married to women that are twice Jessica’s size. In my eyes, she’s a perfect example of a girl that hasn’t lost her beauty just because she’s gained some extra body.

My question is when did being overweight make you ugly? In the Victorian era, large women were treasured and their nude bodies were painted in collages everywhere. In African tribes, the bigger a female is the better. African men believe that larger women are more beautiful then thin women. Joan from Mad Men is adored by everyone and she’s not skinny. So when did the explosion of “thin popularity” begin? I don’t think anyone can say exactly when it began but I do know one thing: It needs to stop! We need to take a stand against discrimination. Not just discrimination against the more curvaceous of our kind but against sex, race, and social standings. I hear it said that today’s society is more accepting to everything but from where I stand, the paucity of acceptance is becoming more and more obvious and harder to ignore.


Similar Articles

JOIN THE DISCUSSION

This article has 45 comments.


gaga-fan28 said...
on May. 7 2010 at 4:55 pm

"The media say being overweight is ugly. what gives them the right to say that?"

Answer: The Consitution grants everyone, even the media, to the right to freedom of speech and freedom of expression. That's what gives them the right. I don't think being overweight is ugly. But I also don't think that the media outright portray overweight as ugly. Sure, the do a lot of the time, but is it really that bad when People magazine has a picture of a celebrity with extra belly fat on the cover, criticizing them? Should you care what People magazine thinks, then? Okay that was kind of a lame example, but in reality, weight is being less discriminative on TV than it used to be. A plus-sized model recently won a season of America's Next Top Model. Plus-sized actress Gabourey Sidibe hosted Saturday Night Live a couple weeks ago. It's not all bad.

"Ever commercial and TV show displays...hates the world, and of, course, she's extremely unpopular."

This is untrue. Every commercial and TV show does not display only girls size 2 and smaller. That's just false. There are plenty of commericials and shows out there with plus-sized models/actresses. The characters they depict in TV shows are not always the antagonist. Consider Mercedes, the proud overweight character on "Glee", who is depicted as confident and kind and talented.

"Fluffy girls don't feel confident because there's not enough effort being put out to change their minds." Whose job is it exactly to inject confidence into people? Isn't confidence something that comes from the inside, and all of that? People can choose what to be affected by. If a girl's confidence comes primarily from watching commercials that only depict skinny girls, as you say, then of course her confidence will be lowered. Confidence is something that one can choose to change about themself, as is weight.

"Every tabloid is screaming "FATTY!" while the majority of them are probably married to women that are twice Jessica's size."

Where exactly did you get this idea about tabloid owners' overweight wives? It doesn't make much sense.

I'm proud to be a size zero and I don't think it makes me any more or any less beautiful than a size fourteen. I just wanted to point out that discrimination works both ways--because I am now 5'5 and my weight has never once reached 100 pounds, people automatically assume that I have an eating disorder or that I am not healthy. But I don't let it get to me.


on Apr. 13 2010 at 7:14 pm
RainbowSpike BRONZE, Columbus, Ohio
1 article 0 photos 14 comments
I love it! You have done a fabulous job! Every girl is beautiful. It's justa matter of knowing your inner beauty lasts forever:)

Pillow BRONZE said...
on Jan. 15 2010 at 7:31 pm
Pillow BRONZE, Spokane, Washington
1 article 5 photos 300 comments

Favorite Quote:
Nothing says oops like a wall of flame.

Girl, you have it right on. I am not anywhere close to a size 14 with a pants size of 18 to 20. I have no hope when it comes to diets or handsome guys at my school. I've been called fat for so long that I beleive it. My friends will hit me for saying that I am fat. I know I'm unappealing but does every guy in elementery to middle school have to mention it? I've been teased for so long that I can't even tell if a guy is being sincere anymore. I wish I had your ability to write what I want to say and to have people understand, like you can. Keep writing Alix.

on Jan. 10 2010 at 7:04 pm
wombatz-rule GOLD, Montrose, Minnesota
15 articles 0 photos 53 comments
This is great. I am definitely not a size two, and not even a size four, and even I feel incredibly self-conscious and fat every day. Why is this? Because of all the negative media. You have such courage to stand up and declare your beauty! In fact, this article proves your inner beauty as well, and the deep, personal voice you have. I love how practical the article is. It states the facts and makes big impression on the reader. Congrats on an excellent article. Keep writing!

Jigjoo GOLD said...
on Jan. 7 2010 at 8:46 pm
Jigjoo GOLD, Many, Louisiana
10 articles 8 photos 30 comments

Favorite Quote:
Hello. My name is Muerte, and I will be your assassin today.

I feel the same way. Kudos to you, darling. Big can be beautiful, too. But still, if a girl gets too big, she should think about losing a little. Just enough not to put excessive strain on one's heart. However, on the converse side, being excessively skinny can also put undo stress upon your organs...We should probably just find a nice, broad, happy medium and shut up. :)